Mike & Cathy's Good Old Days Menu

The menu at Mike & Cathy's Good Old Days offers a comforting blend of classic American and hearty Midwestern fare, presented in a straightforward, casual style. It’s the kind of food that fits well with the relaxed, friendly atmosphere of this lakeside restaurant—perfect for gathering with friends or family over familiar, satisfying dishes.

Guests often come for an evening meal or a weekend treat, enjoying dishes like the rich Super Cut Prime Rib, traditional Corned Beef and Cabbage, or the ever-popular Fish Fry served family style alongside chicken and a variety of home-style sides. Lighter bites such as the Philadelphia Steak Sandwich or Large Brew City Fries make it easy to stop in for a casual lunch or a snack to share.

The menu’s hearty flavors and well-loved recipes complement the welcoming atmosphere, where locals and visitors alike can relax, enjoy a drink, and take in views of the lake. Whether seated indoors or on the lakeside porch, the menu supports conversations and moments that feel easy and unhurried.